Has Modi really delivered?
The summer of discontent is upon us. There is a terrible drought because of the poor monsoon in 2015. This year, apart from the drought, there are many forest fires in Uttarakhand and high food inflation.
The furore over the AgustaWestland helicopter deal, which was never finalised, has been overtaken by the Rafale fighter deal at $50 million per plane. With PM Modi's intervention, 36 aircraft were agreed upon, but there was no agreement on the price, which was substantially higher than that of competitors including Russian and Swedish aircraft.
The coup de grace was the relative silence about the Panama Papers scandal examined by an International Consortium of Journalists, for which PM Modi sidelined the Enforcement Directive which he considered slow, to be replaced by 15 picked persons.
There is a terrible drought because of the poor monsoon last year.
Though Amitabh Bachchan claimed that four foreign offshore investments in his name were fraudulently stated, no action at any stage has been taken with clear results leading to a major return of black money to India.
It should be remembered that the PM had promised a lot more black money while campaigning for election.
The promise of massive job creation has also turned out to be hollow. Barely one lakh jobs have been created leading to increasing unemployment. Even in the education sector costs have risen greatly. The annual fee of Rs 90,000 at IITs of has been increased to Rs 2 lakh, a more than 100 per cent increase.
The emphasis in education was supposed to be on nation building but now has become profit for the institution, and a waning dream for the less privileged. Education for the rich? To be followed by foreign universities coming into India.
Countries like the UK do not give student visas the way they did earlier. Their fees for Indian students are much higher than those of foreign students in India are likely to be.
More seriously many of these decisions have been taken without any public debate. India subsidising foreign education? Is this a core aim of Bharat Mata?
What about economic growth? The government initially spoke of a over 7 per cent growth rate. This is likely to fall because of widespread drought and excess demand for an underfunded MGNREGA, where there is excess demand for rural employment, with rural wage payments coming in more than a month late on the average, despite finance minister Arun Jaitley's earlier predictions.
Late wage payments often lead to the rural poor migrating to other areas, where they do not get the official minimum wage rates, thereby weakening the entire edifice of subsidised rural employment.
smriti-bd_050716015132.jpg
HRD minister Smriti Irani's degree certificates have been missing for three years.
Nobel laureate Angus Deaton argues that India's growth rate is likely to be significantly less than predicted for reasons given above.
On the other hand because of unpaid excess rural demand, poverty is likely to rise. It is perhaps time to question the jettisoning of the Planning Commission, and it's replacement by the skeletal NITI Aayog. Not all new changes are for the better.
Can the NITI Aayog immediately collect all the data for the impact of drought in Gujarat where less than 50 per cent of the population have access to the Narmada Dam water? Where has the much ballyhooed Narmada water flooding the dry plains of Gujarat gone? No plausible official explanation is forthcoming.
Shocking or amusing is the "education of politicians" story.
According to the Delhi University, HRD minister Smriti Irani's degree certificates have been missing for three years. Irani has no explanation why she does not have copies of her own BA certificates. If she lost them, why didn't she apply for replacements?
An education minister who can't look after her own educational certificates? Of course, she did claim after a week's visit to Yale University, that she had got a Yale degree.
Even PM Modi's degrees have caused surprise. His MA degree is on "Entire Political Science"! What does that even mean? There is no "Incomplete Political Science"! His father's name on the duplicate degree is also wrongly spelled, but that is a relatively minor issue, since spelling mistakes are known to occur.
Journalists in Gujarat are eagerly awaiting information on PM Modi's BA degree. All this became possible because Arvind Kejriwal, Delhi CM appealed to the CIC for information.
As the Chinese would say, we are in for "interesting times." more
The furore over the AgustaWestland helicopter deal, which was never finalised, has been overtaken by the Rafale fighter deal at $50 million per plane. With PM Modi's intervention, 36 aircraft were agreed upon, but there was no agreement on the price, which was substantially higher than that of competitors including Russian and Swedish aircraft.
The coup de grace was the relative silence about the Panama Papers scandal examined by an International Consortium of Journalists, for which PM Modi sidelined the Enforcement Directive which he considered slow, to be replaced by 15 picked persons.
There is a terrible drought because of the poor monsoon last year.
Though Amitabh Bachchan claimed that four foreign offshore investments in his name were fraudulently stated, no action at any stage has been taken with clear results leading to a major return of black money to India.
It should be remembered that the PM had promised a lot more black money while campaigning for election.
The promise of massive job creation has also turned out to be hollow. Barely one lakh jobs have been created leading to increasing unemployment. Even in the education sector costs have risen greatly. The annual fee of Rs 90,000 at IITs of has been increased to Rs 2 lakh, a more than 100 per cent increase.
The emphasis in education was supposed to be on nation building but now has become profit for the institution, and a waning dream for the less privileged. Education for the rich? To be followed by foreign universities coming into India.
Countries like the UK do not give student visas the way they did earlier. Their fees for Indian students are much higher than those of foreign students in India are likely to be.
More seriously many of these decisions have been taken without any public debate. India subsidising foreign education? Is this a core aim of Bharat Mata?
What about economic growth? The government initially spoke of a over 7 per cent growth rate. This is likely to fall because of widespread drought and excess demand for an underfunded MGNREGA, where there is excess demand for rural employment, with rural wage payments coming in more than a month late on the average, despite finance minister Arun Jaitley's earlier predictions.
Late wage payments often lead to the rural poor migrating to other areas, where they do not get the official minimum wage rates, thereby weakening the entire edifice of subsidised rural employment.
smriti-bd_050716015132.jpg
HRD minister Smriti Irani's degree certificates have been missing for three years.
Nobel laureate Angus Deaton argues that India's growth rate is likely to be significantly less than predicted for reasons given above.
On the other hand because of unpaid excess rural demand, poverty is likely to rise. It is perhaps time to question the jettisoning of the Planning Commission, and it's replacement by the skeletal NITI Aayog. Not all new changes are for the better.
Can the NITI Aayog immediately collect all the data for the impact of drought in Gujarat where less than 50 per cent of the population have access to the Narmada Dam water? Where has the much ballyhooed Narmada water flooding the dry plains of Gujarat gone? No plausible official explanation is forthcoming.
Shocking or amusing is the "education of politicians" story.
According to the Delhi University, HRD minister Smriti Irani's degree certificates have been missing for three years. Irani has no explanation why she does not have copies of her own BA certificates. If she lost them, why didn't she apply for replacements?
An education minister who can't look after her own educational certificates? Of course, she did claim after a week's visit to Yale University, that she had got a Yale degree.
Even PM Modi's degrees have caused surprise. His MA degree is on "Entire Political Science"! What does that even mean? There is no "Incomplete Political Science"! His father's name on the duplicate degree is also wrongly spelled, but that is a relatively minor issue, since spelling mistakes are known to occur.
Journalists in Gujarat are eagerly awaiting information on PM Modi's BA degree. All this became possible because Arvind Kejriwal, Delhi CM appealed to the CIC for information.
As the Chinese would say, we are in for "interesting times." more
Viewed by 1857
View all 20 comments Below 20 comments
NO! From: Ruchika Lohani To: basava_pk@yahoo.com Sent: Saturday, May 7, 2016 7:12 PM Subject: New post "Has Modi really delivered..." in [Make Delhi Better with Kejriwal] more
May 28
The subject of the post is has Modi delivered, all I can see is AAP bashing, keeping him aside, we are unable to see any tangible action by the central government, if anyone has felt anything tangible, please add, more
May 17
I can see the frustration of MODI'fied members here. Several points of failure and the popularity of AK is causing headache to Saffron gang. Lalitgate, DDCA, Vyapam and many more : PM hides by keeping busy on international tours. The black money and price control was top expectations, aah, sad affair. PM's degree on Entire political science makes sense to the saffron brigade not the rest. Shouting in RS over Augusta is not Swami's style. Had he got proof, he would have grabbed the culprits by law. BJP is using Swami to raise controversy, nothing more. http://zeenews.india.com/news/india/prashant-bhushan-yogendra-yadav-make-fresh-agustawestland-expose-drag-raman-singhs-name_1884488.html more
May 16
ALL BLIND FOLLOWERS OF MODI AND OBVIOUSLY ANTI AK, I HAVE SINGLE LINE ANSWER TO SILENCE U ALL : "UTTARAKHAN FLOOR TEST RESULT AT THE DIRECTION OF SC". AK HAS ADVISED MODIJI NOT GO FOR CREATING CRISIS IN NON-BJP RULE STATES ANY MORE. more
May 11
The post rightly shows the various loose ends in the governance. It may not be palatable to many but facts should not be ignored and pretend as if everything is on a song. I would elucidate a little more on the Rafale deal and what misses our attention. In this deal we went away from the established open tender mechanism and chose the govt to govt route and killed the negotiation of 126 Rafale which was at a concluding stage. In Aug 2014 the then Def Minister , Mr Jaitley mentioned in the parliament that it would take 3-4 years for Dassault to deliver 18 Rafales. The present Defence minister, Mr Parikkar assures twice the number in half the time- this is inexplicable. This is so because currently Dassault builds one Rafale a month and scaling up takes a very long time. A misinformation was going around that the deal to buy Rafale in fly away condition was cheaper than the one which was negotiated for 126 Rafale in open tender process. This is what will appear apparently as because now Dassault is no longer obligated to supply proprietary technology or intellectual property and escaped the requirement of standing guarantee. In fact HAL will get no technology benefit from this deal. Moreover IAF will remain dependent of Dassault for maintenance and spares. Later when Rafale will need to be modernized we will pay more for the upgrades- just as the IAF is doing for upgrading the Mirage 2000. Another interesting gossip going around is the certificate issue of our PM. It will be interesting to see how the truth unfolds. more
May 09
